UPSC Situation at a Look is an initiative of UPSC Necessities to focus your prelims and mains examination preparation on a problem that has been within the information. Each Thursday, cowl a brand new matter in Q&A format and don’t miss MCQs in the direction of the top of the article. This week’s matter is the India-Canada Diplomatic Row. Let’s get began!
When you missed final week’s UPSC Situation at a Look |What has reignited the “One Nation, One Election” debate? from the Indian Categorical, learn it right here.
What’s the difficulty?
The sharp escalation of the diplomatic row between India and Canada, a first-of-its-kind state of affairs in India’s diplomatic relations with the West, has raised considerations about potential ripple results in a variety of areas together with commerce and people-to-people ties.
UPSC Syllabus:
Preliminary Examination: Present occasions of nationwide and worldwide significance
Mains Examination: GS-II: Impact of insurance policies and politics of developed and creating nations on India’s pursuits, Indian diaspora.
Different areas of relevance: UPSC Aspirants will discover it helpful in Essays, and Present affairs for his or her Persona exams.
Query 1: What are the principle causes of the current diplomatic tensions between India and Canada?
The bilateral ties between India and Canada are long-standing and important. Canada is dwelling to a excessive proportion of Sikhs. Nonetheless, the 2 nations’ bilateral relations have been affected by varied points, corresponding to Khalistani separatism and Canada’s place on human rights in India. These points have led to elevated tensions and have impacted diplomatic interactions.
Canada’s allegation about India’s suspected involvement within the killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar
The relations between the 2 nations noticed some bitterness final yr following Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s allegation about India’s suspected involvement within the killing of Khalistani separatist and designated terrorist Hardeep Singh Nijjar in his nation. India denied the allegation as “absurd” and “motivated”, the ties between the 2 nations have suffered a setback since then.
On September 21, India suspended visa providers in Canada, together with e-visa providers. This got here a day after it issued a journey advisory for Indian nationals travelling to Canada, in addition to a warning for the Indian neighborhood in Canada, saying they could possibly be “focused”.
Just lately, the diplomatic stress between India and Canada escalated on Monday (October 14), when India ordered the expulsion of six Canadian diplomats whereas additionally saying its resolution to withdraw the Indian Excessive Commissioner to Canada and “different focused diplomats,” citing safety considerations after Ottawa recognized them as “individuals of curiosity” in its investigation into the killing of Khalistan separatist Hardeep Singh Nijjar.
Canada’s strategy to Khalistani separatism
One of many causes of stress in India-Canada bilateral relations is Canada’s strategy in the direction of Khalistani separatism. India has constantly maintained that the principle difficulty is Canada permitting pro-Khalistani parts to function from Canadian soil with impunity. There even have been cases of pro-Khalistani parts threatening to hurt Indian diplomats.
Shubhajit Roy writes–
“The massive difficulty for India is the protected haven that Canada has supplied to separatist Khalistani teams, and what New Delhi sees because the Liberal Social gathering’s pandering to those teams for votes. Estimates counsel there are 20-25 constituencies the place these votes are essential — and that explains the Trudeau authorities’s soft-pedalling on India’s considerations.”
What we now have seen to our remorse has been the course of Canadian politics the place separatists, extremists forces, a lot of whom overtly advocate violence have been given political area in that nation,” Exterior Affairs Minister S Jaishankar mentioned.
Another challenges have additionally overshadowed India-Canada bilateral relations. For instance, a low level additionally got here in bilateral relations when, after the nuclear exams in 1998, Canada, an advocate of nuclear non-proliferation, closely criticised India.
Factors to Ponder:
— What sort of anti-India actions have been seen in Canada?
— What have been Operation Blue Star and Operation Black Thunder?
Query 2: What could possibly be the implications of an escalating India-Canada diplomatic row?
The deepening acrimony in India-Canada bilateral ties couldn’t solely have an effect on the bilateral relations but in addition hurt India’s international popularity. The potential penalties of the escalating dispute are:
Influence on Financial Relations
The commerce and funding linkages between India and Canada kind an integral part of the multi-faceted partnership between the 2 nations. On this context, the escalating stress between India and Canada has raised considerations about its potential impression on bilateral financial relations. This might have an effect on Canadian pension fund investments value $75 billion in India, the destiny of paused negotiations for a proposed commerce settlement, and the influx of remittances into India.
Ravi Dutta Mishra , Sukalp Sharma write—
In 2022, India was Canada’s ninth-largest merchandise buying and selling accomplice within the Indo-Pacific area, the Thirteenth-largest merchandise buying and selling accomplice globally and the 14th-largest vacation spot for merchandise exports. Main exported gadgets from India to Canada embrace pharmaceutical merchandise (USD 274.05 million); adopted by nuclear reactors, boilers, and elements (USD 195.46 million), electrical equipment (USD 160.68 million), and articles of iron and metal (USD 156.03 million).
“The diplomatic tensions have already impacted negotiations with Canada for a contemporary FTA, which may have meant not solely higher export alternatives for Indian clothes, leather-based, and equipment merchandise in Canada but in addition higher collaboration within the booming providers sector in each nations. Nonetheless, the escalation in stress might nicely imply that the deal might now not be on the desk.”
Nonetheless, it has additionally been mentioned that within the backdrop of the current diplomatic row, there’s nothing a lot to fret about concerning bilateral commerce relations. As a report by assume tank International Commerce Analysis Initiative (GTRI) identified regardless of these important political frictions, the on-ground impression on commerce between India and Canada has been minimal. That is largely as a result of commerce occurs on the non-public sector stage, and neither India nor Canada has launched rules that prohibit the circulation of products or providers.
“For now, the resilience of commerce between India and Canada highlights an necessary lesson — diplomatic tensions, whereas damaging, don’t at all times spell catastrophe for financial ties. However as this dispute drags on, each nations might want to rigorously handle their actions to keep away from a full-blown financial fallout,” GTRI mentioned.
Geopolitical implications
The diplomatic standoff additionally has geopolitical implications for India. If the allegations are confirmed true, India stands to wreck its G20 popularity. The diplomatic disaster additionally extends to nations which share ties with each India and Canada.
Canada is part of the G7 grouping and shares the desk with the US, UK, Germany, France, Italy, and Japan. It additionally shares intelligence with the 5 Eyes grouping — with the US, UK, Australia, and New Zealand. All these nations are additionally shut strategic companions of alternative for India. India has the Quad partnership with the US, Australia, and Japan, and powerful and rising bilateral ties with every of them. The diplomatic standoff has put these nations in a spot.
Factors to Ponder:
— How will the growing stress in India-Canada relations have an effect on the Indian Diaspora?
— How is the Indo-Canadian tiff impacting Indian college students in Canada?
Query 3: Given the current diplomatic row, what steps can India and Canada take to enhance their bilateral relationship?
India has had diplomatic standoffs earlier — with america on the Devyani Khobragade difficulty, with Italy on the Italian marines difficulty, with Norway on the kid providers difficulty, and with Denmark over the extradition of the Purulia arms drop accused. Nonetheless the present state of affairs is qualitatively totally different and far more severe due to the character of the allegation that Canada has made. On this context, each nations should alternate high-level diplomatic dialogues, which may help align their positions on the difficulty and promote mutual understanding.
Karthik Nachiappan writes—
“With out India, Trudeau’s Indo-Pacific technique is out of date. What is probably fortuitous is that each nations share pursuits in defending the worldwide order, balancing China’s rise and behavior, cooperating on points like local weather change, international well being, misuse of digital applied sciences, regulating synthetic intelligence, and assuaging burdens imposed on creating nations. However coping with these challenges requires a political compact that addresses how each nations view Canada’s Indian diaspora and mitigating its worst impulses, notably these fanning separatist embers in India. With out this, Ottawa and Delhi’s nice distance shall be measured not simply by geography however disposition.”
From Editorial “Trudeau has proven irresponsibility in accusing India. He should reply”
Delhi’s sturdy response to the unsubstantiated accusation is comprehensible. It should now work to make sure that Ottawa’s diplomatic offensive doesn’t dent India’s rising ties with the Anglosphere and the West. Delhi should make its case, and be certain that its wider considerations are communicated, particularly to the English-speaking world. However ultimately, it’s in each nations’ curiosity to arrest the slide, and work in the direction of addressing points in good religion.
Factors to Ponder:
— What’s the significance of Canada for India?
— What’s the precept of reciprocity in worldwide legislation
Publish Learn Questions
Prelims
(1) Contemplate the next statements with regard to the G7:
1. The G7 is a proper grouping of main industrialised nations.
2. The European Union has been a part of all working classes of the G7 because the 1981 Ottawa Summit.
3. The Group of Eight was constituted in 1998 as Russia grew to become a member of the grouping.
How lots of the statements given above are appropriate?
(a) Just one
(b) Solely two
(c) All three
(d) None
(2) Contemplate the next nations:
1. United States
2. Australia
3. Canada
4. India
5. United Kingdom
How lots of the above nations are a part of 5 Eyes Alliance?
(a) Solely two
(b) Solely three
(c) Solely 4
(d) All 5
Mains
‘Indian diaspora has a decisive position to play within the politics and economic system of America and European International locations’. Remark with examples. (UPSC CSE 2020)
(Sources: India withdraws its Canada envoy, expels 6 Canadian diplomats , India-Canada ties in numbers, Freedom of speech doesn’t imply freedom to help separatism: Jaishankar on Canada , A short historical past of the Khalistan motion, With India-Canada diplomatic ties in a tailspin, industrial ties may see a chill, Canada must see India, not simply the diaspora)
On your queries and options write at roshni.yadav@indianexpress.com
Subscribe to our UPSC e-newsletter and keep up to date with the information cues from the previous week.
Keep up to date with the most recent UPSC articles by becoming a member of our Telegram channel – Indian Categorical UPSC Hub, and observe us on Instagram and X.