Six Nations: Steve Borthwick's England Successful Ugly However Will Recreation Plan Result In Sustained Success?

Steve Borthwick’s England have two wins from three Six Nations fixtures forward of dealing with the championship’s backside two sides in Italy and Wales – however their recreation plan and the way of their performances have left many questioning them.

Within the opening spherical, a promising first-half show in opposition to Eire in Dublin was rapidly wiped away as England fell 27-10 behind till 4 minutes to play – two late tries burgling a shedding bonus level.

On the second weekend, England welcomed France to Twickenham and customary consensus afterwards was Les Bleus squandered at the least three clear attempt alternatives to maneuver out of sight earlier than a plucky residence facet caught in there and received 26-25 with the ultimate assault.

This weekend, England hosted Scotland at Twickenham, successful by a single level once more as Finn Russell missed a last-gasp conversion to say victory for the away facet.

In truth, England ought to most likely be sat with three defeats from three, such has been the standard of their shows: too detrimental and kick-focused. However the gamers should even be complimented for locating methods to win.

O’Driscoll: I do not get why England play so negatively – there’s far more on this staff

On Saturday in opposition to Scotland, the stats from an England perspective make for grim studying.

Regardless of dealing with one among their greatest rivals on residence soil – Borthwick’s facet had been seeking to beat Scotland for the primary time since 2020 – England ceded 59 per cent territory and 58 per cent possession.

Scotland outscored England by three tries to at least one, carried for practically double the quantity of metres – 933 vs 474 – made 9 line breaks to England’s two and beat 35 defenders to England’s 10.

If Russell had landed even one conversion, England had been crushed. To not thoughts the numerous probabilities ball in hand the guests didn’t take.

Then there’s additionally the problem of the referee. Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend questioned Pierre Brousset’s breakdown penalty determination which allowed Fin Smith to kick England six factors forward within the second half, incorrectly made Russell take the ultimate conversion of the match two metres in from contact as a substitute of the proper mark on the 5, and awarded Tommy Freeman’s first half attempt with no clear grounding.

Former England worldwide Andy Goode posted on X afterwards: “England’s man of the match was the ref Pierre Brousset!”

Talking on ITV Sport on Sunday, former Eire centre Brian O’Driscoll admitted he was at a loss as to England’s present recreation plan, arguing there’s expertise at Borthwick’s disposal to play a unique manner.

“My take was it wasn’t nice viewing. Scotland, in equity, performed all of the rugby and on the steadiness of issues deserved to win. They could not fairly seize it on the finish.

“I watch a number of these England gamers taking part in within the Premiership, they’re much higher in some components.

“They’ve the capability. These guys do it for his or her golf equipment each weekend. I do know membership rugby is not worldwide rugby however there’s far more on this England staff than the expertise we’re seeing on present is being launched.

“Alex Mitchell taking part in for Northampton Saints is unrecognisable comparatively when he is taking part in for England in the meanwhile. There was 16 box-kicks. Ollie Lawrence received hardly any possession within the centre. I do not get it.

“I do not know why there is not a cohesion, why we have not seen three years of Steve Borthwick coming collectively. There isn’t any actual focus or plan. It is stodgy, it is kick-tennis, and it is fairly detrimental.

“It is high quality whenever you eke out one-point victories, however when these outcomes go in opposition to you taking part in that manner – which they are going to at occasions – you’ll get enormous detrimental suggestions. The gang will not be onside.

“They’ve a younger 10 in Fin Smith. When you had an Owen Farrell in there, would he comply with taking part in that manner? Kicking the leather-based off the ball? Definitely as an outside-centre, I would not take pleasure in simply chasing all of it day lengthy. There isn’t any enjoyable in that. You need to play with ball in hand.”

In final 12 months’s Six Nations when England beat Eire at Twickenham in the perfect efficiency of the Borthwick period, they performed with out abandon and positively, offloading and connecting with ball in hand to create probabilities and rating tries.

The following seven occasions England confronted tier-one opposition they misplaced: France in Lyon, New Zealand in Dunedin and Auckland, New Zealand (once more), Australia and South Africa at Allianz Stadium Twickenham and Eire in Dublin. In each a type of Exams, Borthwick’s facet surrendered second-half leads.

Maybe such a run has induced the coaches and gamers to tighten England up, however the proof is there that the squad are taking part in inside themselves and replicating the final three performances would go away the probabilities of continued, long-term success unsustainable.

Six Nations fixtures: Spherical 4

Saturday March 8

Eire vs France (2.15pm)
Scotland vs Wales (4.45pm)

Sunday March 9

England vs Italy (3pm)

British & Irish Lions tour of Australia on Sky Sports activities

Sky Sports activities will solely present the 2025 British and Irish Lions tour of Australia, with all three Exams in opposition to the Wallabies and 6 warm-up matches to be proven solely reside.