Hostel residents on the Panjab College (PU) have raised considerations over being charged a further 5 per cent Items and Providers Tax (GST) on their month-end canteen payments, successfully resulting in funds exceeding the Most Retail Value (MRP) of packaged items. Since MRP is inclusive of GST, retailers are legally prohibited from levying further GST on such merchandise.
College students have accused canteen contractors of overcharging, non-compliance with metrology requirements, and imposing illegal prices. The hostel canteens provide each packaged objects corresponding to biscuits, chips, and goodies, in addition to freshly ready meals like paranthas and burgers. Whereas some college students settle for GST on unpackaged meals, they argue that making use of it to MRP-inclusive merchandise is unjust.
“I used to be levied a Rs 30 service cost and a 5 per cent GST on my whole invoice final month. Moreover, there was a discrepancy additionally,” stated Nisha Sharma, a resident of ladies hostel 2.
Lack of transparency
Many college students have reported discrepancies of their month-to-month canteen payments, with variations starting from Rs 30 to Rs 150 between their precise purchases and the ultimate quantity charged. When questioned, canteen workers attributed these discrepancies to “service tax and 5 per cent GST”.
Including to their frustration, the hostel college students obtain solely the entire invoice quantity on the finish of the month, with none breakdown of particular person prices, taxes, or surcharges. Furthermore, college students should not supplied with correct month-to-month invoices. “As a result of an absence of transparency, many college students don’t even realise they’re being overcharged. If we protest, it could actually pressure our relationship with the canteen homeowners. Some canteen employees behave rudely once we ask them the breakdown of payments,” stated Arshdeep Singh, a boys hostel resident.
College students have raised points on inconsistencies in software of GST in mess canteens. Canteen employees admitted to charging GST solely on unpackaged items, whereas others claimed that 5 per cent GST was levied on your entire invoice. Moreover, a couple of hostel canteens don’t keep separate registers for packaged and unpackaged items. “Sustaining two separate registers is simply too hectic, so I cost 2.5 per cent GST as an alternative of 5 per cent,” admitted a canteen contractor.
Story continues beneath this advert
Authorities step in
In response to the complaints, Panjab College College students’ Council (PUSC) President Anurag Dalal lately carried out raids in hostel canteens and messes, together with at ladies hostel 1 and ladies hostel 2, to handle the scholars’ considerations. “The official college worth listing states that GST ought to solely be utilized the place relevant, but canteens are nonetheless charging it on packaged merchandise like biscuits. It is a continuation of wrongful practices, which we’re actively working in opposition to,” Dalal said.
Most scholar leaders had been unaware of those points nevertheless, some scholar leaders argued that whereas raids create consciousness, they serve merely as a publicity software slightly than a method of efficient decision.
“Actual activism is lacking. The PUSC lacks authorized energy to behave on such points; it operates as a glorified strain group. Not like scholar councils in different universities, which derive authority from their constitutions, the PUSC has restricted affect. Earlier, members might escalate such points to the Senate members, however with the Senate’s energy deteriorated, its legitimacy has weakened. Provisions needs to be made to take authorized motion in opposition to these violating tender agreements,” stated Mukul, who ran as an Impartial for PUSC presidential candidate 2024.
Amit Chauhan, Dean of Pupil Welfare, Panjab College acquired complaints from ladies hostel 10 and ladies hostel 6. “They weren’t sustaining separate registers for taxable and non-taxable objects. We contacted the mess and the wardens and these points haven’t been raised once more, subsequently have been resolved. We additionally urged PUSC President Anurag Dalal to verify that separate lists of taxable and non-taxable objects are maintained in mess canteens throughout his raids of hostel canteens,” Chauhan stated.
