Generally, one story can span a complete profession or that profession could be dominated by one story. That was the case with Chitra Subramaniam and her decade-long investigation into the Bofors bribery rip-off. The story broke in 1987 through broadcasts of the Swedish state radio and subsequently by way of Subramaniam’s exposes, first, in The Hindu and later in The Indian Categorical and The Statesman.
In her upcoming e book Bofors Gate (revealed by Juggernaut), one chorus that runs by way of as her main remorse: the field/bins with between 500-1,000 pages of secret Swiss paperwork — despatched to India in 1997 — stay unopened.
The paperwork had been handed over to then Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Director Joginder Singh at a public ceremony in Bern (Subramaniam was current). It’s not clear whether or not there have been one or two bins.
The e book has over a dozen references to the “unopened bins” with the creator writing, “Over time, politicians have advised me that the closed field serves them higher than if it was opened. I discover these arguments stunning as a result of they strike on the very core of what my nation is…I imagine the time just isn’t far when the field in India will likely be opened on public demand.”
Sparking a possible controversy, Subramaniam has written that whereas the paperwork had been transferred to India in 1997, they remained unopened in 2025. She asserts, “No political celebration has had the braveness to open them for concern of discovering out what they comprise — not even the Nationwide Democratic Alliance (NDA) that rode to energy in 2014, on the promise that the corrupt can be booked and that Indian taxpayers would lastly know the reality…”
Once more: “India’s premier investigative company pretended the bins with the key paperwork from Switzerland have by no means been opened so far, and successive governments have used the ‘closed’ bins as political soccer with out a take care of the reality, or for the self-respect of a nation.”
She additionally describes the bins because the “elephant within the room” and concludes, “Contemplating Bofors and corruption made political careers and received elections for the opposition, their incapacity to have a look at the paperwork raises many questions, an important one being: who features most from the silence on the paperwork?’’
Story continues beneath this advert
And the final, definitive sentence of the e book: “The unopened bins with the CBI comprise the self-respect of India.”
The CBI had ploughed by way of its Bofors case for 21 years and at last closed the case in 2011. Whereas defendants like Win Chadha and Italian businessman Ottavio Quattrocchi and most of the key members of the CBI’s probe staff (together with then Director Joginder Singh) are not any extra, others recall that the key Swiss paperwork despatched to India in 1997 had been pivotal to the chargesheet they filed in 1999.
They, thus, contradict assertions made within the e book.
Amongst those that spoke to The Indian Categorical was O P Galhotra, who was the Superintendent of Police (SP) assigned to the Bofors case and went on to turn into the company’s Joint Director. He stated: “I joined the staff quickly after the paperwork had been handed over to the CBI and the funds detailed in fashioned the very foundation for submitting the costs in opposition to Ottavio Quattrocchi and the Hinduja brothers. It was due to the main points within the paperwork, for example, that the Hindujas joined the investigation in India. The bins had been very a lot opened.’’
One other key member of the CBI probe staff within the Bofors case was N R Wasan, Deputy Inspector Basic (DIG), who had dealt with the case for 15 years. He advised The Indian Categorical that after the Director introduced them, the bins had been carried to the chamber of the Further Classes Decide Ajit Bharihoke within the Tis Hazari Courtroom, opened by the decide after which handed over to the CBI as case property.
Story continues beneath this advert
He recalled, “The key paperwork had been a court-to-court switch between Switzerland and India in 1997 and had been subsequently addressed to the designated court docket. The seals had been opened in entrance of the designated decide after which handed over to us for the investigation. The paperwork had been invaluable for the CBI for submitting the cost sheets since they contained the whole cash path and each banking transaction.”
When advised about this response from CBI investigators, Subramaniam advised The Indian Categorical: “Bofors was not an atypical case. In India, it introduced a Authorities down and in Switzerland, legal guidelines had been modified on account of the investigation. The CBI ought to have advised us what they discovered and shared the data with us. Why was all of it finished so quietly?’’
Her e book particulars how the story blurred the road between her skilled and private. As an illustration, she describes how in 1990, when she was in sizzling pursuit of the kickback recipients, at any time when the cellphone rang at dwelling, her four-year-old son Nikhil would shout, “Mummy, Bofors talking.”
